How to Invest in Short-Term Rentals: A Step-by-Step Guide for Beginners

Short-term rentals, akin to hotels, are properties rented out on a nightly basis rather than through monthly or annual leases. These rentals are fully furnished and equipped to meet the needs of guests during their stay. In most jurisdictions, a stay of 30 days or less is classified as "short-term."

Typically, owners purchase short-term rental properties as secondary residences or vacation homes, without intending to live in them. With the advent of platforms like Airbnb and VRBO, real estate investors have recognized the substantial profit potential in short-term rentals. What was once seen as a side venture for passive income has evolved into a thriving industry with significant profit margins.

Why Invest in a Short-Term Rental Property?

High Profit Potential

Short-term rentals can be exceptionally profitable. Given the nature of these rentals, investors can earn more monthly compared to traditional rentals, provided they have secured a desirable property in a popular location.

Consider this: If a property charges $300 per night and is booked for 18 nights in a month, the gross income could reach $5,400. After accounting for rental-related expenses—such as taxes, mortgage payments, and maintenance—let’s assume the monthly costs total $2,500. In comparison, a traditional three-bedroom home in the United States typically rents for around $1,300 per month. Clearly, a short-term rental can be significantly more profitable.

High Demand

Securing a property in a prime tourist destination at a reasonable price can lead to substantial returns. The demand for vacation rentals has surged, with platforms like Airbnb and VRBO gaining significant market share from the hotel industry. As long as thorough research is conducted to select a property that meets key criteria, finding tenants should not be challenging.

Future Growth Potential

Properties located in sought-after vacation spots often appreciate well over time. Investing in an area experiencing growth can be a wise decision. Additionally, short-term rentals offer the flexibility to adjust rates in response to market-wide price increases, unlike traditional rentals that are tied to long-term leases.

Advantages of Owning Short-Term Rentals

While higher income potential is a key benefit, there are several other advantages to owning a short-term rental property:

Lower Maintenance

Contrary to expectations, short-term rentals can be easier to maintain than long-term rentals:

Property managers can handle cleaning and preparation between guests.

Cleaning fees often cover future maintenance costs.

Frequent turnovers allow for regular cleaning, enabling early detection of potential issues.

Schedule Flexibility

Owners have complete control over their rental property’s availability. They can decide when to rent it out and when to use it for personal vacations or maintenance.

Pricing Optimization

Owners can adjust rental prices based on demand. For example, prices can be increased during peak seasons, weekends, or holidays to maximize revenue. In some cases, offering special rates for extended stays can help maintain competitiveness while still ensuring higher overall earnings.

Ideal for New Investors

Short-term rentals tend to appreciate over time, making them an attractive investment for new investors. As the property’s value increases, so does its potential for generating income.

Tax Benefits

Short-term rental properties offer several tax advantages:

Deductible expenses: Marketing, management, upkeep, insurance, business meals, educational expenses, and eligible home offices are all deductible.

Travel deductions: Frequent trips to manage the property can be deducted, as can vehicles primarily used for the rental’s upkeep.

Depreciation: Immediate deductions can be claimed for expenses on furniture, appliances, and entertainment items.

Challenges of Short-Term Rentals

Despite the advantages, short-term rentals come with certain challenges:

High Maintenance Requirements

Without a property manager, operating a short-term rental can become a demanding task, involving:

Booking management

Tenant screening

Payment collection

Property maintenance

Marketing

Additionally, managing a rental property requires strong customer service and marketing skills, which can pose a steep learning curve for some.

Unpredictable Cash Flow

While short-term rentals can generate higher income than long-term rentals, they lack the predictability of steady cash flow. Events like pandemics or seasonal fluctuations can lead to vacancies and cancellations, affecting profitability.

Limited Screening Processes

Unlike long-term rentals, where tenants undergo rigorous screening, short-term rentals often rely on limited information, such as online reviews. The higher turnover rate also increases the risk of property damage.

Owner-Paid Utilities

Unlike long-term rentals, where tenants typically cover utility costs, short-term rental owners are responsible for paying for utilities such as water, electricity, and internet.

Neighbor Concerns

Frequent guest turnover can disrupt the neighborhood’s peace, potentially leading to conflicts with neighbors, especially in communities with families seeking a quiet environment.

Regulatory Restrictions

Short-term rental properties may be subject to strict regulations, such as homeowners’ association (HOA) rules or local government restrictions. Violating these regulations can result in legal challenges.

Identifying a Profitable Property

Before investing in a short-term rental property, thorough research is essential.

Market Evaluation

Begin by assessing whether the market is worth entering. Popular tourist destinations like Austin, Texas, and New York, New York, are often competitive, driving up property prices. Research visitor statistics and economic trends to determine the market’s potential for appreciation and occupancy.

Seasonality Consideration

Consider the seasonality of the market. Some locations experience seasonal tourism, affecting occupancy rates. A year-round tourism market, such as Asheville, North Carolina, is ideal. However, investing in markets with robust seasonal demand can also yield profitable returns.

Demand Analysis

Assess the area’s occupancy rates using data from platforms like AirDNA. Aim for markets with occupancy rates above 65% to ensure a strong investment.

Recession Resistance

Evaluate the property’s ability to withstand economic downturns. Established tourist destinations with year-round attractions, such as theme parks, are generally more recession-resistant than smaller markets with niche tourism appeals.

Regulatory Compliance

Familiarize yourself with local regulations governing short-term rentals. Some areas may have stringent requirements or even ban such rentals altogether.

Property Analysis and Revenue Estimation

After identifying a potential market, conduct a thorough analysis of the property’s quality and revenue potential.

Revenue Calculation

To estimate potential revenue, multiply the occupancy rate by the nightly rate and the number of days in a month. For example, a 75% occupancy rate at $300 per night over 30 days could generate $6,750 per month. Adjust this figure based on seasonal variations and cleaning fees, if applicable.

Expense Estimation

Estimate expenses, including mortgage payments, insurance, property management fees, taxes, and maintenance costs. Subtract these expenses from the estimated revenue to determine net income.

Final Considerations

Before purchasing a short-term rental property, ensure that the potential return on investment aligns with your financial goals. Conduct thorough research and consider all factors to make an informed decision.

In previous post: "What Does Off-Market Commercial Real Estate Mean?"